Underinsurance...results can't be trusted

Free Case Review

Underinsurance, in the context of insurance law in Florida, refers to a situation where an individual or entity carries liability insurance coverage, but the coverage limits are insufficient to fully compensate the injured party when a liability claim is made. This can lead to a gap between the at-fault party’s insurance coverage and the actual damages incurred by the injured party.

Understanding the legal definition and significance of underinsurance in Florida is essential for insurance policyholders, legal professionals, and anyone involved in personal injury cases. This comprehensive overview explains the key elements of underinsurance, its relevance in various legal contexts, and the legal framework governing it in the state of Florida.

Key Elements of Underinsurance in Florida:

  • Inadequate Insurance Coverage: Underinsurance occurs when the at-fault party or the person responsible for an accident or incident has insurance coverage, but the coverage limits are insufficient to fully compensate the injured party for their damages.
  • Coverage Gap: A coverage gap arises when the injured party’s damages exceed the available insurance coverage from the at-fault party’s liability policy. In such cases, the injured party may not receive full compensation for their losses.
  • Underinsured Motorist Coverage: In the context of auto insurance, underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage is a specific type of insurance that policyholders can purchase. UIM coverage is designed to protect the policyholder if they are injured by an at-fault driver who lacks adequate liability insurance.
  • Maximum Recovery Rule: In Florida, the maximum recovery rule states that the injured party is generally entitled to recover damages up to the available insurance policy limits of the at-fault party’s liability coverage. If the damages exceed those limits, the injured party may seek additional compensation through their UIM coverage.

Underinsurance in Various Legal Contexts in Florida:

Underinsurance is relevant in various legal contexts in Florida, including:

  • Auto Insurance: The most common context in which underinsurance is encountered is in auto insurance. When an individual is involved in a car accident and the at-fault driver has insufficient liability insurance to cover the injured party’s damages, the injured party can turn to their own UIM coverage for additional compensation.
  • Personal Injury Claims: In personal injury cases where the at-fault party’s insurance coverage is insufficient to fully compensate the injured party for medical expenses, property damage, lost wages, and other losses, underinsurance may become a significant issue.
  • Property Damage Claims: Underinsurance may also be relevant in property damage claims, such as when a property owner’s coverage limits are insufficient to cover the full cost of repairs or replacement of damaged property.
  • Liability Claims Against Businesses: In cases where businesses or commercial entities are responsible for injuries or damages, their liability insurance coverage may be insufficient to cover the total amount of compensation owed to injured parties.

The Legal Framework for Underinsurance in Florida:

The legal framework governing underinsurance in Florida includes several key aspects:

  • Florida Statutes: Florida law contains statutes that govern underinsured motorist coverage, including requirements for insurers to offer UIM coverage to policyholders.
  • Insurance Contracts: Auto insurance policies in Florida often include provisions related to UIM coverage. Policyholders have the option to purchase this coverage, and the terms and limits of UIM coverage can vary depending on the policy.
  • Maximum Recovery Rule: The maximum recovery rule in Florida determines the injured party’s entitlement to damages based on the available liability coverage of the at-fault party. When this coverage is insufficient to cover the damages, the injured party may seek additional compensation through their UIM coverage.
  • Claims Process: When dealing with an underinsured motorist claim in Florida, policyholders must follow the claims process outlined in their insurance policy, which typically involves notifying the insurer, providing documentation of damages, and working with the insurer to reach a settlement.

Significance of Underinsurance in Florida:

Underinsurance is significant in Florida for several reasons:

  • Protection for Injured Parties: Underinsured motorist coverage provides protection to individuals who are injured in accidents where the at-fault driver lacks adequate liability insurance. It ensures that injured parties are not left without compensation for their losses.
  • Additional Compensation: UIM coverage allows injured parties to seek additional compensation when the at-fault party’s insurance coverage is insufficient to cover the full extent of their damages. This can be crucial for covering medical expenses, property damage, and other costs.
  • Peace of Mind: UIM coverage provides peace of mind to policyholders, knowing that they have an additional layer of protection in case they are involved in an accident with an underinsured driver.
  • Fair Compensation: Underinsurance helps ensure that injured parties receive fair compensation for their losses, even if the at-fault party’s liability insurance is inadequate.

Navigating Underinsurance in Florida:

To navigate underinsurance effectively in Florida, consider the following steps:

  • Review Your Insurance Policy: Policyholders should review their auto insurance policy to understand the terms and limits of their UIM coverage.
  • Seek Legal Counsel: In complex cases where insurance companies dispute coverage or refuse to provide the expected compensation, it may be advisable to seek legal counsel to protect your rights and interests.
  • Document Damages: In personal injury or property damage claims, document all damages and losses to support your claim for additional compensation through UIM coverage.
  • File Timely Claims: Timely file claims with your insurance company, adhering to the requirements and procedures outlined in your policy.
  • Negotiate or Litigate: In cases where the insurance company does not offer fair compensation, consider negotiating or, if necessary, litigating to seek the compensation you believe you are entitled to.


Underinsurance in Florida refers to situations where the at-fault party’s liability insurance coverage is insufficient to cover the injured party’s damages. Understanding the legal framework and significance of underinsurance is essential for policyholders, legal professionals, and individuals involved in personal injury and property damage cases.

UIM coverage provides an additional layer of protection, allowing injured parties to seek fair compensation when the at-fault driver is underinsured. Navigating underinsurance effectively involves understanding insurance policies, documenting damages, filing timely claims, and, in complex cases, seeking legal counsel to protect your rights and interests in the state of Florida.

If you need a Property Damage Lawyer Contact us today!

For more Property Damage terms visit our glossary page.

Related Articles